With the team filled with Scottish imports, it was a Welshman that rejuvenated the 'Heathens' fortunes. Caesar Augustus Llewellyn Jenkyns arrived from Woolwich Arsenal in May 1896 and was made captain. At fourteen stone and five foot ten he had a reputation for crunching tackles and fierce shoulder charges and was exactly what the team needed. Newton Heath topped the table until December, wehen after Jenkyns had been sent off - the first 'Heathen' to be dismissed in the League - they lost 3-0 to Notts County at Bank Street.
A 2-0 victory over Arsenal in April guaranteed the runners up spot but they finished bottom of the four team mini-League in the test matches.
The club progressed to the F.A. Cup quarter finals, beaten for the second successive year by Derby County.
Newton Heath's registered colours are given as white and blue in the Association of Football Statistics annual, and this information was confirmed by contributor Pete Wyatt. Mark Graham has discovered a reference in a mtch report that the 'Heathens' weore white shirts in the game at Walsall in September. The design of our graphic is based on the style of the shirt worn the previous season and from later photographic evidence. In all probability the committee would have decided upon the change on purely pragmatic grounds. White shirts remained the cheapest option.
There is less certainty concerning the club's change kit. We believe the shirts were probably red and black stripes, which we have contemporary evidence were worn in 1898. It is less likely that the earlier green and gold striped shirts worn in 1893 had been retrieved.